Friday, July 28, 2023

Weekend Listomania: Special "The Happy (Mouth) Organ" Edition

[I first posted a version of this one in 2008(!), back when the world and this blog were barely removed from diaper-wearing. As is my wont, I've done some rewriting and added/switched a couple of entries, just so you don't find me unduly indolent. Enjoy. -- S.S.]

Well, it's Friday and you know what that means. Yes, my Asian ambulance chaser Hop-Sing and I are off to beautiful Mar-a-Lago, Florida, where we're going to have a sleep-away party with Arizona Governor-in-Her-Own-Mind Kari Lake while we attempt to find the Israeli antiquities the Former Guy seems to have misplaced.

In any case, posting by moi will necessarily be somewhat fitful for a few days as a result.

But until then, as always, here's a fun project for you all to contemplate:

BEST HARMONICA SOLO ON A POST-ELVIS POP OR ROCK RECORD!!!!!

By "best," we mean either in a blues or non-blues idiom, just to keep it totally wide open. And by "solo" we mean anything of any length, even if it's just a riff.

Totally arbitrary rule: Don't even try to nominate something by that fat guy from Blues Traveller. The Hendrix of the Blues Harp my ass....

Okay, that said, here's my totally top of my head Top Fifteen:

15. The Prostitutes -- Down Below

A great New York City rock band in the tradition of the Velvets and the Heartbreakers, and some of the most fabulously blues-wailing harp (courtesy of NYC fixture Jon Paris) on a sort of Doors-Meet-the- Smithereens song you'll ever hear.

14. The Pretenders -- Middle of the Road

Chrissie Hynde -- first she growls, then she makes her harp sound like a stray cat in heat. Can we just admit she's the greatest female rocker who ever was or will be and be done with it already?

13. The Weasels -- Coral Reef

My old garage band chum Glenn Leeds waxes mournful on the opening harp intro. (I'm doing the attempted Robin Trower guitar later in the song, but that's a story for another time).

12. Jimmy Reed -- Honest I Do

The very definition of sly concision. (Hey -- I made a couplet!!!!)

11. The Broadcasters -- Down in the Trenches

One of the great lost singles of the 80s (produced by Wayne Kramer of the MC5, incidentally). These guys should have been superstars, no question about it. BTW, I have a video of me singing "Route 66" and "Gloria" at a party with three of them; get me hammered some time and I might even show it to you.

10. Procol Harum -- Your Own Choice

That solo at the end is about as gorgeously lyrical as can be, and it's played (uncredited) by the great Larry Adler. And if you don't know who he is, hang your head in shame and then go read his bio.

9. Bruce Chanel -- Hey Baby

That's Delbert McClinton playing the harmonica stuff. I seem to recall it was a huge influence on a certain four-piece band from the UK.

8. The Beatles -- I Should Have Known Better

Uh...a case in point.

7. J. Geils Band -- Whammer Jammer

The aptly named Magic Dick. 'Nuff said.

6. Stevie Wonder -- For Once In My Life

As brilliantly structured and performed a solo as you'll ever hear on any instrument.

5. A tie --

The Rolling Stones (Mick Jagger) -- Stop Breaking Down

-- and --

The Rolling Stones (Brian Jones) -- Good Times Bad Times

Amplified Chicago blues harp in the former, acoustic country blues harp in the latter, both brilliant.

4. Bob Dylan -- I Want You

Short, melodic, and it frames the song perfectly, front and back. Anybody who says Dylan's a crappy harp player really isn't listening....

3. XTC -- Ballad of Peter Pumpkinhead

Blues harp on a revisionist folk rock song. Andy Partridge is god, obviously.

2. Creedence Clearwater Revival -- Run Through the Jungle

John Fogerty channels Howlin Wolf. It doesn't get any spookier, song OR harp part.

And the number one, no question about it, all time coolest harmonica solo on a hit record is --

1. Slim Harpo -- Baby Scratch My Back

Hands down, the down and dirtiest blues performance ever to crack Top 40 radio.

Alrighty now -- what would YOUR choices be?

And have a great weekend, everybody!!!

23 comments:

pete said...

Steve Wonder could make a dozen entries by himself. I'm partial to Boogie On, Reggae Woman - "Can I play?"

Anonymous said...


On the Road Again - Canned Heat
My Babe - Juke - Little Walter
Heart of Gold - Neil Young
One Way Street - Aerosmith
Nobody's Fault But Mine - Led Zeppelin
East-West - Butterfield Blues Band
Do It Now - Medicne Head
School - Supertramp
Sinister Minister Bela Fleck & the Flecktones (Howard Levy
Keep On Chooglin' - Creedence (since Steve already took Run Through the Jungle)
All Around Man - Rory Gallagher Old Grey Whistle Test https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3jrUKo3yZ_8
Rolling stones - Miss You (Sugar Blue)
Good Morning Little Schoolgirl - Grateful Dead
When the Levee Breaks - Led Zeppelin
Four Until Late - Cream
Property of Jesus - Pretenders https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dUp__usC6xY

VR

Anonymous said...

I forgot.

Finger Tips - Stevie Wonder

VR

Anonymous said...

And:

Low Rider - War
Inside Looking Out - Grand Funk Railroad

VR

Cleveland Jeff said...

Too Many Drivers- Paul Butterfield's Better Days

Anonymous said...

Dyna-Soar · Roland Kirk · Quincy Jones And His Orchestra: Charles McCoy on harmonica
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zClLSn-Lurw

Untitled Blues · Roland Kirk with Sonny Boy Williamson
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJfcXsRAw1w

I Think She Likes Me · Treat Her Right: Jim Fitting on harmonica
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k8f8HciNGwM

One Way Out · Sonny Boy Williamson
https://youtu.be/x2An9nyzMW4

Democracy · Leonard Cohen: Dino Soldo on harmonica
https://youtu.be/ifwtWF485HU

The River · Bruce Springsteen
https://youtu.be/_Jw8P7gHxzI

- Paul in DK

steve simels said...

Ooh…I’d forgotten that Trat Her Right song…thanks!

MJConroy said...

I see "Low Rider" by War was already listed. It blew my mind when I found out the harmonica player in War was a white guy from Denmark, Lee Oskar. He has his own harmonica company.

Alzo said...

Phil Lynott's thunderous 'Ode to a Black Man' features scorching harp from (!) Huey Lewis:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nIPDs8ao0B0

This great number was later restated masterfully by Detroit's mighty Dirtbombs.

Anonymous said...

John Sebastion/ Lovin' Spoonful- Night Owl Blues
Paul Butterfield- Mystery Train
Magic Dick & Stevie Wonder definitely.....
rs

BG said...

"I'm A Man" - Yardbirds ... Relf and Beck doing the call and response ...

pete said...

You can always tell Sebastian's harp-playing.

dorethyroad@aol.com said...

Let's not forget the late, great
Norton Buffalo -,rob

Allan Rosenberg said...

Born in Chicago - Paul Butterfield Blues Band

Nine Below Zero - Sonny Boy Williamson II

Muddy's Wheels - The Broadcasters (
Steve 'Muddy' Roues of The Broadcasters is a modern master of the blues harp.)



That's a good batch

Captain Al

ChrisE said...

I Don't Wanna Go - Paul Butterfield (from the album "PUT IT IN YOUR EAR") - great solo at the end of the song.

Anonymous said...

No Charley/Charlie Musselwhite yet?

I love the whole "Stand Back" album especially "Christo Redemptor."

Long Train Runnin' - Doobie Brothers (Tom Johnston)

Done Somebody Wrong - Allman Brothers Band (Thom Doucette)

Tangled Uo In Blue - Bob Dylan

If You Want to Get to Heaven - Ozark Mountain Daredevils

Shenandoah - Charlie McCoy

Room to Move - John Mayall

Custard Pie - Led Zeppelin

Tonio K - Not Fade Away (Peter Case harp)

Parchman Farm - Cactus

He Ain't Heavy (He's My Brother) - Hollies

Stone Cold Fever - Humble Pie

Going Back to Colorado - Zephyr

Blues Is Blues - Kellie Rucker

honorable mention - Beau Brummels - Laugh Laugh; Black Crowes - Hotel Illness; Tom Petty - You Don'Know How It Feels/Mary Jane's Last Dance; Humble Pie - Red Light Mama, Red Hot; Cactus - Alaska

VR

steve simels said...

Okay, I haven’t heard the. Tonio K, and I’m a huge fan. Thanks for the tip, VR!

Anonymous said...

Line-up on Tonio K "Not Fade Away"

Vocals: Tonio K.
Harmonica with Vocals: Peter Case
Electric Guitar, Vocals: Albert Lee
Guitar, Vocals: Sonny Curtis
Keyboards: Glen D. Hardin
Acoustic Bass: Joe B. Mauldin
Drums, Percussion: J.I. Allison

From album "The Crickets and Their Buddies

Track List

1) That'll Be The Day 2:16
Backing Vocals – Dave Carlock
Saxophone – Joe Sublett
Vocals – Rodney Crowell
Written-By – Holly*, Allison*, Petty*

2) Rave On 1:51
Vocals – Jason Everly, Phil Everly
Written-By – Tilghman*, Petty*, West*

3) Not Fade Away 3:28
Harmonica – Peter Case
Vocals – Tonio K.
Written-By – Holly*, Hardin*, Petty*

4) Someone, Someone 4:15
Guitar – Eric Clapton
Piano – Jeffery "CJ" Vanston*
Vocals – Eric Clapton
Written-By – Greines*, Petty*

5) The Real Buddy Holly Story 4:35
Banjo – Herb Pedersen
Fiddle – Jerry Goodman
Lead Vocals – Sonny Curtis
Written-By – Sonny Curtis

6) Everyday 2:27
Acoustic Guitar – J.D. Souther*
Cello – Ron De La Vega
Lead Guitar – Sonny Curtis
Written-By – Hardin*, Petty*

7) Love You More Than I Can Say 3:27
Vocals – Nanci Griffith, Sonny Curtis
Written-By – Allison*, Curtis*

8) Heartbeat 2:19
Cowbell – Pat McInerney
Harmony Vocals – Bobby Vee
Vocals – Nanci Griffith
Written-By – Montgomery*, Petty*

9) Blue Days, Black Nights 2:10
Acoustic Guitar – Bobby Vee, Robby Vee
Backing Vocals – Nanci Griffith
Lead Vocals – Bobby Vee
Written-By – Ben Hall (2)

10) Learning The Game 3:23
Cello – Ron De La Vega
Piano – Albert Lee
Vocals – Albert Lee
Written-By – Buddy Holly

11) Well... All Right 2:26
Backing Vocals – Nanci Griffith, Sonny Curtis
Vocals – Waylon Jennings
Written-By – Holly*, Allison*, Mauldin*, Petty*

12) Think It Over 2:52
Harmony Vocals – Graham Nash
Lead Vocals – Graham Nash
Saxophone – Bobby Keyes*
Written-By – Holly*, Petty*

13) Oh Boy! 2:11
Backing Vocals – Nanci Griffith, Sonny Curtis
Vocals – John Prine
Written-By – Tilghman*, Petty*, West*

14) I Fought The Law 2:12
Vocals [All The Parts] – Vince Neil
Written-By – Sonny Curtis

15) Love's Made A Fool Of You 3:15
Backing Vocals – J.I.*, Keith Allison
Bass – Ronn Lynn
Guitar – Johnny Rivers
Vocals – Johnny Rivers
Written-By – Montgomery*, Holly*

General Credits
Vocals – Albert Lee, Sonny Curtis
Electric Guitar – Albert Lee
Guitar – Sonny Curtis
Keyboards – Glen D. Hardin*
Acoustic Bass – Joe B. Mauldin*
Drums – J.I. Allison*
Percussion – J.I. Allison*
Producer – Greg Ladanyl*
Engineer – Greg Ladanyl*, Ronn Lynn
Executive-Producer – Burt Stein
Liner Notes – Charlie Springer
Mastered By – Steve Hall

Anonymous said...

No one mentioned "What I Like About You" by the Romantics?

VR

Allan Rosenberg said...

The Romantics still owe me $5.00 from the time they shared the PA with The Hounds at Copperfield's in 1977. I let them slide for the money so they could get MacDonalds after the gig rather than go hungry. True story.

Captain Al

Anonymous said...

MYSTIC EYES - THEM!!!

Indiara Sfair - House of the Rising Sun
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pOsynqyg8Rs

Graveyard Train - Creedence
The Way It Goes - Little John Chrisley
Mellow Down Easy - Little Feat (Kim Wilson harp)
Good Morning Little Schoolgirl - Gov't Mule (Hook Herrera)

VR

Anonymous said...

A few more:

Groovin’ (single version) – Young Rascals (Michael Weinstein)
Lie No Better – Delbert McClinton
Suicide Blonde – INXS (Charlie Musselwhite sampled)
Sweet Lady Genevieve – Kinks (underrated song) (no solo but …)

British Invasion harp/monica:

I’m a Loser – Beatles
I Just Want To Make Love To You – Rolling Stones (Brian Jones)
Catch Us If You Can – Dave Clark Five (Denis Payton)
Mess of the Blues/Love Me, Baby – Peter and Gordon (Brian Jones)
Don’t Bring Me Down – Pretty Things
Looking For My Life – Gerry & the Pacemakers

VR

M_Sharp said...

"Juke" - Little Walter, great drums by Elga Edmonds, aka Elvin Evans